Senior Portfolio Seminar

CRWR 453 Spring 18

February 27, 2018
by thom18
Comments Off on Emma Thom: “Going Diamond”

Emma Thom: “Going Diamond”

I find it more difficult to discuss craft in a non-fiction collection of essays, but I noticed after a few pages that Gerard seems to be playing with the structure of the story. It is organized in scenes that alternate … Continue reading

February 22, 2018
by thom18
Comments Off on Emma Thom: “Cracked”

Emma Thom: “Cracked”

If any of you have read it, this story reads like one of Rebecca Lee’s short stories from her collection Bobcat. It is strange and unnerving, from the rooms without doors, to the surveillance, to the disappearance, all of it is … Continue reading

February 22, 2018
by kirven18
Comments Off on Kollin’s Response to “Cracked”

Kollin’s Response to “Cracked”

In “Cracked,” the third chapter of Elizabeth Strout’s bestselling novel, Anything is Possible, I was most interested in the characters. The chapter’s main character, at least in contrast to Yvonne and Karen Lucie, is not entirely confident or assured. I … Continue reading

February 22, 2018
by odonnell18
Comments Off on Maggy’s “Cracked” Response

Maggy’s “Cracked” Response

Unlike the other linked stories, it was unclear to me how these stories were linked until the end. There was no unifying Lucy Barton. As far as craft is concerned, I think the first paragraph is interesting. We learn a … Continue reading

February 19, 2018
by gullicksen18
Comments Off on Lydia’s response to “Dark Lady”

Lydia’s response to “Dark Lady”

Dark Lady by Margaret Atwood was an interesting final piece of the Gavin puzzle. Or the Constance puzzle, though, to me, Gavin seems to be the biggest part of all three stories, even though he is the worst of all … Continue reading

February 10, 2018
by thom18
Comments Off on Emma Thom: “Mother-Father God”

Emma Thom: “Mother-Father God”

I can remember, as a little girl, feeling close to God, knowing he existed. I was baptized and raised in the church by parents who were active members and believed themselves to be “faithful.” While in Nashville we went from a … Continue reading

February 8, 2018
by kirven18
Comments Off on Kollin’s response to Windmills

Kollin’s response to Windmills

 I hadn’t expected that the second chapter of Anything is Possible would not be about Tommy, an elderly man we’d met prior. Instead, we’re introduced to a new character, a character to whom I found myself expressing sympathy. If I … Continue reading

February 8, 2018
by odonnell18
Comments Off on Maggy’s “Windmills” Response

Maggy’s “Windmills” Response

More so than Atwood, I am struggling to write about Strout’s work. The world is clear and intensely developed, but it isn’t fantastic. Strout has copied our real world, with all of its complexities and layers, and has copied it … Continue reading

February 7, 2018
by thom18
Comments Off on Emma Thom: “Windmills”

Emma Thom: “Windmills”

Like Tommy Gutpill, Patty Nicely is concerned with her appearance, her reputation, and the perception of her family members and students. She becomes obsessed with Lila Lane’s harsh words, reciting “Fatty Patty” to herself even in the privacy and loneliness … Continue reading